Author: Tara Tiger Brown

  • How much nature time and how often is enough?

    How much nature time and how often is enough?

    White et al. (2019) found people who spent at least 120 minutes a week in nature were more likely to report good health than people who spent none. Li et al. (2026), found frequent visits mattered more than total duration. A comparison of where the two studies agree, where they differ, and what it means in practice.

    How much time and how often do you need to spend outdoors for it to offer health benefits, and does it matter whether you do it one weekend or spread it across the week?

    That is the question most readers bring to this research, and it’s one I share. A recommendation that only works on a free Saturday in good weather will not help on a rainy Tuesday when you have only twenty minutes to spare. I compared a study that PaRx cites (White et al., 2019) to a new meta-analysis (Li et al., 2026) to review if we’ve learned anything new. What I found is that although they use different methods, and don’t agree on everything, there is some agreement.

    Two studies

    White et al. (2019) analyzed survey data from 19,806 adults in England, examining the link between self-reported health and wellbeing and the amount of recreational time spent in nature over the preceding seven days.

    In contrast, Li et al. (2026) conducted a meta-analysis synthesizing findings from 168 eligible studies published between 1980 and 2025.

    The first study is a large, consistent snapshot of one population at one time. The second is a synthesis across populations, places, and study designs, with the strengths and the messiness that come with pooling work other researchers carried out in different ways.

    White et al. (2019)Li et al. (2026)
    DesignSingle cross-sectional survey. Provides a single population snapshot at one point in time. Can identify associations but cannot establish causality.Meta-analysis. Top tier synthesis of multiple studies, it offers high generalizability and statistical power.
    Who was studied19,806 adults in England, 2014/15 and 2015/16168 eligible studies from 1980 to 2025
    What was measuredSelf-reported health and wellbeingStress, anxiety, depression, mood
    Nature doseMinutes in nature in the last 7 daysFrequency and duration of weekly green-space visits
    Headline findingGood health first significantly more likely at 120 minutes a weekOne visit or one hour reached about half the modelled maximum benefit

    Agreement: Duration

    Both studies show the association between nature exposure and the outcomes measured rising at low exposure and then levelling off, although the evidence takes different forms: Li et al. (2026) fitted a dose-response curve to pooled data, whereas White et al. (2019) estimated odds ratios across discrete duration bands. In both cases, most of the associated benefit is concentrated at the low end of the exposure range, with little additional gain at higher doses.

    In White et al. (2019), participants who reported at least 120 minutes of recreational nature time per week were significantly more likely to report good health and good wellbeing than participants who reported no nature time in that week. The likelihood increased with weekly duration and reached its maximum at approximately 200 to 300 minutes per week, with no further gain beyond that range. Two hours therefore marks the threshold at which a difference first became statistically detectable in that survey, and three to five hours marks the point at which the curve reached its highest value.

    Li et al. (2026) report a corresponding pattern in pooled form. In their dose-response models, one visit per week, or one hour per week in total, corresponded to approximately 50 percent of the modelled maximum benefit. Four visits per week, or four hours per week, corresponded to approximately 90 percent, and six visits or eight hours to approximately 99 percent. These percentages are shares of the maximum response estimated by the model, and they convey proportion. The first visit and the first hour account for a large share of what the model estimates, and each additional visit or hour contributes less than the one preceding it.

    Read together, the two studies converge on the same conclusion regarding time. The peak reported by White et al. (2019) at 200 to 300 minutes aligns closely with the four-hour point on Li et al. (2026)’s pooled curve, at which approximately 90 percent of the modelled maximum had been reached. The convergence operates at different levels of analysis: White et al (2019) establish the claim at the level of the weekly aggregate, whereas Li et al. (2026) establish it at the level of the individual visit, where frequency is an independent predictor. 

    In both papers, a modest amount of nature exposure counts, and it counts early on. In White et al. (2019), it is 120 minutes per week, and in Li et al. (2026), it is a single weekly visit, or 60 minutes. A short visit therefore counts in two ways, as a meaningful dose for one visit, and as a contribution to the weekly total.

    Disagreement: Frequency

    The genuine disagreement between the two papers concerns frequency.

    White et al. (2019) found that how the 120 minutes were accumulated made no difference in their data. A single longer visit and several shorter visits that added up to the same total were associated with similar outcomes, so the weekly total was what mattered in that survey.

    Li et al. (2026) found the opposite pattern in their meta analysis. Frequency mattered more than duration, which means the number of separate visits carried more weight than the total length of time. In other words, returning to green space over several days supports mental health more strongly than one visit.

    The studies measured different outcomes, in different populations, with different methods, so a direct comparison is challenging. Frequency may matter more for those day-to-day mental health responses than it does for a general rating of health, or the difference may reflect how each study counted a visit. 

    Methods

    White et al. (2019) used data from the Monitor of Engagement with the Natural Environment survey, collected in England in 2014/15 and 2015/16. Participants reported their recreational visits to natural environments in the previous seven days, recorded in blocks of 60 minutes, and they rated their own health and wellbeing. The researchers then compared those ratings across levels of weekly nature time, from none through to 360 minutes or more, while accounting for other factors that shape health. The design is cross-sectional, which means exposure and outcome were measured at the same time in the same survey.

    Li et al. (2026) followed the systematic approach a meta-analysis requires. They searched three databases for studies from 1980 to 2025, screened the 92,430 records their search returned, assessed full texts, and kept the studies that met their eligibility criteria. From the eligible studies they extracted dose-response data on how often people visited green space and how long they spent there each week, and how those doses related to stress, anxiety, depression, and mood. They then fitted a generalized sigmoid dose-response model, a curve that rises and then levels off, to describe how the response changed as the dose increased.

    Limitations

    The study by White et al. (2019) shows association. People who spent more time in nature reported better health, and people in better health may also find it easier to get outside, earn more, or live closer to good green space. A single survey taken at one time cannot settle the direction of that relationship on its own, however large the sample is.

    The meta-analysis pools a much wider evidence base, and pooling brings its own limits. The studies Li et al. (2026) synthesized were largely observational and varied in how they defined a visit, a green space, and a mental health outcome. The percentages in the dose-response curve are shares of a modelled maximum, so 50 percent means half of the largest benefit the model estimated, and it does not mean symptoms fell by 50 percent for an individual person. The findings describe population averages, and each response will vary with sleep, stress, weather, and geography. 

    In Practice

    Translating the science to practice, the results indicate a frequent, short, repeatable visit to a place you can reach easily. This takes into account weekly total over time (White et al., 2019), and the pattern Li et al. (2026) found strongest.

    That is the basis of a sit spot. Choose one nearby place, a bench under a tree, a corner of a park, a stretch of trail you already know, and you return to it for a short stay, sitting and noticing what is there. Returning to the same place across the week builds frequency without demanding a long block of time, and the minutes accumulate toward the weekly totals. Familiarity does some of the work here, because you spend less of each visit orienting yourself and more of it actually paying attention to your surroundings, the light, weather, and seasonal change.

    Recommendations:

    • Start where you are. One short visit is a meaningful start.
    • Return when you can. Several short visits over 7 days that add up to 120 minutes.
    • Let longer visits be a bonus. A longer outing is welcome when you have the time for it.

    If a week gets away from you, and you get outside once, or not at all, the research gives you no reason for guilt. The curves describe averages across thousands of people, and they describe a direction you can return to the following week. If you take one thing away from this, it’s this, the practice works best when it is easy enough to repeat.

    References

    Li, J., Gong, P., Schumann, G., Webster, C., & Jiang, B. (2026). A generalized relationship between dose of greenspace exposure behaviours and mental health responses. Journal of Environmental Psychology, 115, 103211. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jenvp.2026.103211

    White, M. P., et al. (2019). Spending at least 120 minutes a week in nature is associated with good health and wellbeing. Scientific Reports, 9, 7730. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-019-44097-3

  • Biophilia Hypothesis

    Biophilia Hypothesis

    The biophilia hypothesis is the idea that humans have an innate tendency to seek connection with living systems including plants, animals, landscapes, water, sunlight, and other forms of nature.

    The term was popularized by biologist E. O. Wilson in his 1984 book Biophilia. Wilson argued that because human beings evolved for most of their history in close relationship with natural environments, our nervous systems may still be especially responsive to certain natural patterns.

    That does not mean every person automatically loves every aspect of nature. It means that, on average, humans may be predisposed to notice and value life-supporting environments.

    The evolutionary logic

    For early humans, paying attention to nature had practical consequences:

    – Water could mean survival.

    – Fruit-bearing plants could mean food.

    – Animal movement could signal danger or opportunity.

    – Open views could make threats easier to detect.

    – Trees and sheltered spaces could provide protection.

    – Seasonal changes could signal when to move, hunt, or gather.

    Over many generations, environments containing cues of safety, resources, and possibility may have become emotionally attractive.

    What it looks like today

    glee-devereaux
    Glee Devereaux

    Biophilia may help explain why people often find these experiences calming or compelling:

    – Looking at trees or moving water

    – Caring for plants

    – Watching birds or animals

    – Walking in forests

    – Seeing daylight and natural materials indoors

    – Preferring rooms with windows or views

    – Feeling restored by gardens, parks, or coastlines

    A related idea is attention restoration theory by Stephen and Rachel Kaplan: natural environments may hold attention in a soft, effortless way, giving directed attention—the effortful kind used for work and problem-solving—a chance to recover.

    Another related concept is stress-reduction theory, associated with Roger Ulrich’s work, which proposes that certain natural scenes can produce relatively rapid physiological calming: lower stress, slower heart rate, and easier emotional regulation.

    Important caveat

    The hypothesis is influential, but it is not a single proven law of human psychology. Researchers debate:

    – How much of nature preference is biological versus cultural

    – Whether all humans share the same preferences

    – Which natural environments are universally appealing

    – How much the benefits come from nature itself versus exercise, novelty, social contact, or escape from noise

    So the strongest version is not “nature heals everyone in the same way.” A more careful version is:

    Humans appear to have recurring, partly evolved tendencies to respond positively to many forms of living nature, and those responses can support attention, mood, and stress regulation under the right conditions.

    For a sit spot, biophilia suggests that sitting quietly in one familiar natural place may work partly because it gives the nervous system repeated, low-demand contact with living processes such as light shifting through leaves, birds moving, weather changing, and the body gradually learning that stillness is safe.

    Sit. That’s it.

  • What 33 brain studies suggest about time in nature

    What 33 brain studies suggest about time in nature

    The review brought together 33 studies involving 2,101 participants. Each study recorded a brain measure during exposure to a real, virtual, or imagined natural environment. Researchers also used a standard mood questionnaire. This design let them see whether subjective reports tracked physiological change.

    The clearest finding is a small-to-moderate, measurable shift

    The research team at the University of Houston found a consistent overall pattern. Nature exposure was associated with improved survey scores. It was also associated with measurable shifts in brain activity.

    The pooled numbers came from nine studies with controlled comparisons. Survey scores showed a small-to-moderate, statistically reliable improvement, with a Hedges’ g of 0.30. Brain measures showed a somewhat larger shift, with a Hedges’ g of 0.43. Those figures suggest a real signal across the controlled studies, while the variation between studies calls for a measured interpretation.

    The emotional pattern depended on who was taking part. In clinical populations, the clearest change was a reduction in negative emotions. In healthy volunteers, roughly equal proportions of studies reported brighter moods and an easing of negative feelings. The paper describes this as a “more balanced psychological response,” with neither direction clearly dominant.

    Real natural settings accounted for 61 percent of the studies. Visual imagery, including virtual reality and imagination-based tasks, accounted for 39 percent. Real-world immersion appeared to produce the strongest positive effects, while screen-based nature or imagined nature still showed benefits. The review points toward direct contact with nature as the strongest form of exposure while leaving room for other formats when they fit someone’s circumstances.

    The brain may register a change before words do

    Electroencephalography or EEG, appeared in 82 percent of the studies. Other studies used functional magnetic resonance imaging or functional near-infrared spectroscopy. Together, these methods gave researchers several ways to observe how brain activity shifted during exposure to nature.

    One functional magnetic resonance imaging study found increased functional connectivity between the default mode network and attention-related brain networks during nature exposure, a pattern the authors interpret as potentially consistent with attention restoration, though that same study found no significant change in the participants’ mood questionnaire scores. Functional near-infrared spectroscopy studies showed reduced activity in the prefrontal cortex, a pattern linked with relaxation.

    Brain activity sometimes shifted even when participants reported feeling about the same. That pattern suggests questionnaires may miss part of the response, which helps explain why the pooled brain effect was somewhat larger. The neurophysiological results also showed substantially more variation across studies than the questionnaire results, an important caveat when interpreting what the brain measures mean.

    The authors interpret these results through two established theories: Stress Reduction Theory proposes that nature scenes engage the parasympathetic nervous system, the branch involved in rest and physiological recovery. Attention Restoration Theory proposes that natural settings give directed attention a chance to rest. The paper also places these short-term responses inside the “neural exposome,” the idea that environmental exposures shape brain health across a lifetime. Within that framework, stress impacts brain health through sensitization of the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis. These mechanisms remain proposed explanations for the observed associations.

    The evidence is promising, with important limits

    The authors rated 88 percent of the studies as having methodological weaknesses. The pooled effect sizes rest on nine controlled studies, while the effects varied considerably across that group, moderately for survey outcomes and substantially for brain measures. Seventy percent of the studies took place in Asia, so transfer to Western populations remains a question for future research.

    Most participants were healthy adults. Seven studies included clinical populations. Children made up 1.4 percent of all participants. These gaps narrow the populations to which the findings can be applied with confidence.

    The brain results showed substantially more variation than the questionnaire results. More work needed before researchers can specify which brain changes matter most or how long they last.

    Let the practice stay modest

    Regular time in a nearby natural setting may be associated with a small-to-moderate shift toward emotional ease. Brain measures suggest that part of the response may happen beneath conscious awareness.

    The review offers stronger support for real-world immersion than for screen-based exposure. It also suggests that imagined nature or visual imagery can carry some benefit. For daily life, the useful emphasis is regular contact in a place you can return to. Brief repeated visits can become more workable than waiting for a special outing.

    A nearby place can support a daily practice

    The evidence is promising enough to make a daily sit spot practice worth trying as one supportive part of life.

    Choose a nearby place with natural features, then sit there regularly at an unhurried pace. Let your attention settle on what is actually present: the movement of leaves, the texture of bark, the changing light, or the sound of birds. A neighbourhood tree, a garden, or a small park can hold this practice. And if you need to stay at home, a balcony, porch, or even windowsill works too.

    sean-sitspot
    Sean Bonner at a Sit Spot Practice with Maria Koehn

    Citation

    Daube, A., Lima-Carmona, Y. E., Hernández Solís, D. G., & Contreras-Vidal, J. L. (2026). A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis of EEG, fMRI, and fNIRS Studies on the Psychological Impact of Nature on Well-Being. International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 23(3), 377. DOI: 10.3390/ijerph23030377.

  • Sit Spot Club Hosts

    In 2026 I invited Forest Therapy guides to host Sit Spot Club sessions in their communities. I am grateful for their generosity and talent connecting residents of Metro Vancouver to nature. By joining their sessions I have gotten to know them better and their unique way of guiding. If you are interested in having a truly immersive experience, please reach out to any of these guides or join one of their public sessions.

    Lynn Fearn

    Lynn guides in West Vancouver and Bowen Island at Rivendell Retreat Centre. She is a retired nurse and certified by Global Institute of Forest Therapy and Nature Connection and Forest Therapy Hub. Connect with Lynn.

    Sit Spot Club Hosts

    Glee Devereaux

    Glee is a talented musician, teacher and Forest Therapy guide based in Vancouver. She is a passionate volunteer spending her time caring for parks and animals. Connect with Glee.

    Sit Spot Club Hosts

    Maria Koehn

    Maria is a certified Sound Healer and ANFT Forest Therapy Guide in Surrey. I’ve been to two of her sound bath sessions and I feel relaxed and rejeuvenated afterwards. She hosts sessions in her studio and in the community. Sign up for her next event here.

    Sit Spot Club Hosts

    Tamiko Suzuki

    Tamiko organizes social and environmental justice events. She is running for Vancouver Park Board to upgrade neglected parks, expand the tree canopy, restore natural ecosystems, and grow the green spaces. Vote for Tamiko and connect with her here.

    Sit Spot Club Hosts
  • Solo or Guided? Comparing Mindful Forest Walks

    Summary

    Both solo and guided mindful forest walks reduce stress, improve mood, and increase nature connectedness. Guide-led programs tend to add greater gains in self‑esteem, emotional regulation, social bonding, and sometimes larger anxiety and physiological effects than self-guided walks, though findings vary.

    Main outcome differences

    Self-guided experiences reliably improve mood, anxiety scores, and nature connectedness, while guided programs more often add effects on self‑esteem, emotional shifts, and social engagement.

    • Both effective Self-guided and guided forest therapy produced significant improvements in negative affect, mood states, anxiety, and nature connectedness compared with routine activities or controls [1] [2] [3].
    • Guided advantages Guided programs showed additional increases in self‑esteem compared with routine activities and, in several studies, greater reductions in state anxiety and total mood disturbance than self‑guided immersion [1] [4].
    • Different experiential emphasis Qualitative analyses report that self-guided sessions are more associated with introspection and inward focus, whereas guided sessions emphasize emotional change and social interaction [3].

    Physiological outcomes

    Comparative physiological data show consistent overall benefits from forest exposure but mixed differences between solo and guided formats depending on measures and contexts.

    • General physiological effects Forest-based interventions reduce systolic and diastolic blood pressure and salivary cortisol on average across studies of urban residents [5].
    • Heart rate Reductions in heart rate have been reported in both guided and self‑guided sessions across diverse parks and seasons [6].
    • Blood pressure and stress hormones Blood pressure responses varied between guided and self‑guided sessions and across individuals and settings; some studies found guided sessions produced larger or more consistent Systolic Blood Pressure decreases and lower stress‑hormones than strolling alone [6] [7].
    • Therapist-led clinical advantage Guided forest immersion led by clinical therapists was associated with greater short‑term reductions in state anxiety [4].

    Psychological outcomes

    Psychological outcomes across formats include depth of reflection, emotion regulation, social connectedness, and mindfulness.

    • Mood and anxiety Both formats improved mood and reduced anxiety in randomized crossover and controlled trials [2] [9] [10].
    • Nature connectedness Participation in either self‑guided or guided immersion increases connectedness to nature; some studies report stronger or more complex cognitive–emotional responses when a guide structures the experience [1] [2] [11].
    • Introspection versus social bonding Self‑guided therapy is repeatedly reported to foster introspection and inner-focused reflection, while guided programs foster emotional shifts and opportunities for social interaction and shared processing [3].
    • Mindfulness depth Insufficient evidence to conclude that certified guide‑led sessions reliably produce deeper mindfulness states than self‑guided sessions; many comparative trials did not include validated “mindfulness depth” measures or produced mixed results.
    • Emotional nuance and stability Guided formats can elicit deeper emotional processing and more complex cognitive responses to nature, and may buffer external variability (e.g., noise, weather), supporting more consistent experiential outcomes [11].

    Moderators and practical interpretation

    Differences between self-guided and guide-led outcomes depend strongly on participant characteristics, facilitation type, environment, and dose; these moderators explain many inconsistent findings. Choice of format should align with intended goals (introspection, clinical symptom reduction, social support, or scalable public health delivery).

    • Participant experience Increases in nature connectedness and mood were larger among participants with low prior forest‑bathing experience in some studies, affecting whether guided facilitation adds benefit [6].
    • Environment and sensory context Plant diversity, ambient sound levels, light, and season influenced mood and physiological responses, sometimes interacting with whether sessions were guided or self‑guided [6].
    • Dose and session length Longer or multi‑session forest therapy (≥20 minutes and repeated sessions) produced larger blood pressure and cortisol reductions in pooled analyses [5].
    • Facilitator type matters Clinical therapist‑led sessions (psychologists/therapists) have shown larger short‑term mental‑health gains and reduced outcome variability compared with unguided immersion in at least one study, and one retrospective analysis suggested higher economic value for therapist‑led delivery [4].
    • Practical recommendation Use self‑guided formats when the goal is personal reflection, scalability, or low cost; choose certified or therapist‑led programs when targeting clinical anxiety, structured emotional processing, social cohesion, or when environmental distractions must be managed.

    References

    [1]W. S. Shin and J.-G. Kim, “The influence of Self-Guided and Guided Forest Therapy Program on Students’ Psychological Benefits,” Journal of people, plants, and environment, vol. 26, no. 2, pp. 169–179, Apr. 2023, doi: 10.11628/ksppe.2023.26.2.169.

    [2]W. S. Shin, I. K. Seong, and J.-G. Kim, “Psychological Benefits of Self-Guided Forest Healing Program Using Campus Forests,” Forests, vol. 14, no. 2, pp. 336–336, Feb. 2023, doi: 10.3390/f14020336.

    [3]J.-G. Kim and W.-S. Shin, “Forest Therapy Alone or with a Guide: Is There a Difference between Self-Guided Forest Therapy and Guided Forest Therapy Programs?,” International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, vol. 18, no. 13, p. 6957, June 2021, doi: 10.3390/IJERPH18136957.

    [4]R. Rivieccio, F. Meneguzzo, G. Margheritini, T. Re, U. Riccucci, and F. Zabini, “Therapist-Guided Versus Self-Guided Forest Immersion: Comparative Efficacy on Short-Term Mental Health and Economic Value,” Behavioral science, vol. 15, Nov. 2025, doi: 10.3390/bs15121618.

    [5]Q. Qiu et al., “The Effects of Forest Therapy on the Blood Pressure and Salivary Cortisol Levels of Urban Residents: A Meta-Analysis,” International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, vol. 20, no. 1, pp. 458–458, Dec. 2022, doi: 10.3390/ijerph20010458.

    [6]“Forest bathing in Metro Vancouver, Canada : a randomized crossover study examining health outcomes and environmental and vegetation influences,” Mar. 2025, doi: 10.14288/1.0448266.

    [7]K. Igawahara, T. Kagawa, N. Takayama, and B.-J. Park, “Research on the Effect which a Guide Brings about in a Forest Walk,” Journal of the Korea Society of Computer and Information, vol. 70, no. 5, pp. 597–600, Mar. 2007, doi: 10.5632/JILA.70.597.

    [9]H. Ochiai et al., “Physiological and psychological effects of forest therapy on middle-aged males with high-normal blood pressure,” International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, 2015, doi: 10.3390/IJERPH120302532.

    [10]A. Muro et al., “Forest bathing and hiking benefits for mental health during the COVID-19 pandemic in Mediterranean regions,” European Journal of Forest Research, vol. 142, no. 2, pp. 1–12, Feb. 2023, doi: 10.1007/s10342-023-01531-6.

    [11]P. E. Loyola, “Evaluación de la influencia de un guía en prácticas de inmersión en la Naturaleza: conexión y actitudes de valoración de la Naturaleza en espacios verdes urbanos,” Jan. 2024, doi: 10.7764/tesisuc/agr/88525.